How our AWR critics taste together in a panel, replicated for our AWR community with hotpot after to round up the evening.

Event was hosted by Jackie Ang MW, AWR's Founding Critic. (Photo Credit: AWR)
The second instalment of our Critics Panel series was hosted by Jackie Ang MW, AWR Founding Critic. Following the format we introduced at The Critics Panel, No. 001, attendees spent the evening tasting the way our critics do in a panel — blind, without producer or price, scoring against the AWR methodology before any reveal.
Where No. 001 was a single flight designed to articulate our metholodgy, No. 002 was structured around our actual AWR Tier 1 Categories. There were two flights, organised by styles the way our Tier 1 is done. First ive Chardonnays first, three Rhône varietals after — set out to answer that.

This Tier 1 Category of Burgundy and Burgundy-adjacent wines was a line up of all Chardonnay. Amongst which was one wine from Burgundy, one from Margaret River and three from China. While in a normal AWR panel tasting, where region is revealed, region is not revealed until the end for this tasting.
The E.J. McDougall Margaret River Chardonnay 2024, imported by Vin-Ex Wines, was the clear stand-out of the range, with many mistakening it for Burgundy. The precision in the winemaking with depth. One of the event attendees noted it as “Butterscotch popcorn on the nose. Good acidity, intensity and finish. Good purity of fruits on entry, some whole bunch notes, good mineral backbone.” On the other hand, many participants thought that the Domaine Numa Cornut Meursault 2023 was from Australia, due to its lean and reductive style.
Out of the three Chinese Chardonnay, all of which imported by Wine Kool, the Chateau Nine Peaks Classic Chardonnay 2023 was said to be the most promising. It was said to “opened after awhile” by one of the event attendees.

This Tier 1 Category of Rhône and Rhône-varietals wines proved interesting. There was only one from Crozes-Hermitage, which was the Domaine Gilles Robin Cuvée Alberic 2022. For this flight, participants correctly identified the Rhône wine from the Australian wines. Praises were sung for both the 2023 E.J. McDougall, with attendees split between the Old Vine Shiraz and Old Vine Grenache.
The tasting closed within an hour and the room turned communal for Japanese style hotpot. Hotpot, which originated in China during the Zhou to Han dynasties, has now become a widespread favourite with countries around China. Many countries in Asia have their own versions of hotpot, including both Korea and Japan.

The broth is arguably the essence of the hotpot, and attendees savoured the slow-cooked Kinmedai broth, with quality seafood from Neta Seafood sourced by Soshinsen. The room turned jovial, with participants discussing their favourite wines and pouring each other wines to share. Seafood such as scallops, madai, snow crab and Nakanishi wagyu were added to the broth, alongside daikon, tofu, mizuna, shungiko and shiitake mushrooms. Furthermore, rice were added to the remaining broth in true Japanese shime style, as the finishing course.

Event was held at Neta Seafood at East Coast Road. Thank you Vin-Ex Wines and Wine Kool for the wines.