We explore three wines to debunk the outdated ABC myth, showcasing producers outside of Burgundy.

A Chardonnay lineup at a recent AWR Critics Panel 002, a blind tasting format led by an AWR Critic.
Somewhere along the line, the cool kids of the wine world decided that Chardonnay is uncool. By cool kids, I mean if you are referring to who The New York Times reported back in 1995.
The "Anything But Chardonnay" (ABC) movement was popularised as a consumer trend and industry catchphrase as a nod to the Chardonnay fatigue. Critics the likes of Robert Parker preferred the concentrated, ripe style of Chardonnay with new French oak, with his influence widespread from the late-1980s to the mid-2000s. But while Parker championed benchmark, rich Chardonnays from quality producers the likes of Kistler and Aubert, commercial mass-market companies tried to mimic that richness on a budget with overripe Central Valley Chardonnay grapes and heavy use of oak chips.
Unlike what the people perpetuating this ABC movement some two or three decades later do not understand is that ABC was not a rejection of well-made high quality Chardonnay. It was a backlash to the mass produced style of Chardonnay that is overly oaked, full malolactic conversion and with some residual sugar — the style of cheap Chardonnay coming out of California and Australia during the late 1980s and 1990s.
In this article, we look into some 90 pointers AWR critics have rated, and recommend producers for you to try that make these high quality rich Chardonnays.
Our Lead Founding Critic Tan Ying Hsien MW is not one to be easily impressed by Chardonnay. Yet, he noted that this wine was “very fine, with restrained power and intensity” and “the mid-palate complexity suggests a very good premier cru or grand cru”. He did point out that “it lacks the density of a top vintage”.
Read this article free.
Create a free account and read one members’ article or full score every month.
Already have an account? Sign in
Or become a member for every score, tasting note and article, plus at least SGD 100 off every event ticket. From SGD 10.67 a month.